Bay Area Insurance Shop, Inc.

Clearwater, FL

(844) 699-2769
Car Home
Founded in 1996

Time is valuable - Save yours - Let us shop for you!

Bay Area Insurance Shop opened in 1996 in Clearwater, Florida and has grown and thrived in the 20-plus years since. We are a family-owned and operated agency, started by two sisters who simply wanted to help people buy better insurance for their home, family, and business.
With a sunny, friendly, cheerful attitude and a willingness to genuinely help & educate clients, Bay Area Insurance Shop works hard to earn the business and respect of our clients. We don't just sell insurance products. We listen to clients, figure out what they need most, help them find the best solutions, and let them know we care. That's how we earn their business and their trust and loyalty.

States Served
Maryland, Georgia, Florida, Ohio
Personal Insurance
Automobile
Boat
Collectible Auto
Condo
Flood
Home
Mobile Home
Motorcycle
Other
Personal Watercraft
Pet
RV
Renters
Special Event
Umbrella
Valuable Items
Companies We Work With
Progressive Insurance
Rockingham Casualty Company
Hagerty
Liberty Mutual
Travelers
Safeco Insurance
Universal Property & Casualty Insurance
SBLI
American Traditions Insurance Company (ATIC)
Nationwide
Zurich North America
Mercury Insurance Group
Foremost Insurance
United States Liab
RLI Corp
Clear Blue Insurance Group
TypTap Insurance
Hiscox Ins Co Inc.
Berkshire Hathaway
Bristol West Insurance Co
US Assure
American Modern Insurance Group
Ascendant
UPC Insurance
Burns & Wilcox
Ryan Turner Speciality
Lloyd's
Edison Insurance
Burlington Insurance Company
Universal North American
J.C. Taylor
AIG
Dairyland Insurance Co
FrankCrum
Jewelers Mutual Insurance Company
biBERK
American Collectors Insurance
Bankers Insurance Group - FL
Surplus & Excess Lines
Florida Peninsula
James River Insurance Company
Citizens
AmWINS Group
K&K Insurance Group
National General Insurance (GMAC)
Markel Specialty
Bay Area Insurance Shop, Inc. Team
  • Michele Horwitz - Owner
    Michele Horwitz
    Owner
  • Megan Baker - Agent
    Megan Baker
    Agent
  • Ron Horwitz - Customer Service Representative
    Ron Horwitz
    Customer Service Representative
Connect With Us